Timbercraft Timber Frame Homes  Built For Life Timbercraft Homes Books and Articles
   



This new collection of articles from
Fine Homebuilding magazine
brings together 26 exceptional
country homes including
Japanese Influence of a Western
House,
a Timbercraft project.
     

   
Japanese Influence on a Western House
A courtyard garden and an exposed timber frame are among the inspirations from another culture.
by Judith Landau

Like most clients, Peter and Annette Lancy arrived for their first design conference with a box full of books and magazines. But unlike other clients, the Lancys had tagged many pictures of Japanese houses. One stunning image showed a spacious room with shoji screens drawn back to reveal a garden framed by a sweeping roof and its supporting columns. Another photograph showed an elaborate network of roof beams, one of which had been fashioned from a gracefully arched tree trunk. Annette was enchanted by the serenity of the Japanese rooms, and Peter admired the sophisticated joinery required to connect the timbers.

Because the temperate coastal environments of the Pacific Northwest and Japan are similar, it seemed likely that traditional Japanese architectural forms included design solutions that would work equally well on Bainbridge Island in Washington. Low-pitched roofs to shed rain, broad eaves to protect wide expanses of windows and doors, and verandas that bridge indoor and outdoor spaces are features that would work well in the mild Northwest climate (photo below left). But other than these obvious physical features, which I admired for their simplicity and primitive strength, I knew very little about the construction of a Japanese house. And while I intended to borrow a few ideas, I felt my efforts wouldn't be successful unless I understood how the Lancys planned to use their house and how a Japanese house is organized.




What the owners really needed-


As our discussion moved from design philosophy to specific requirements, I learned that Peter and Annette planned to raise sheep and llamas on their property, so the house had to function as a farmhouse-sturdy and easy to clean. Wood floors, for example, were out of the question because their two dogs might damage them. The Lancys wanted a formal living/dining room for family holidays and three large bedrooms to accommodate visiting children and grandchildren.

Peter and Annette expected to spend most of their time in the kitchen/family room, but Annette would need generous studio space for spinning and storing wool. There would also have to be plenty of wall space for their art collection and lots of shelves for all their books. Peter grows orchids, so he hoped we could find a space where heat and humidity could be monitored.

The gently rolling terrain of the Lancy's eight-acre property slopes to the south and east. Two meadows had been carved out of second-growth fir and alder. The house would share the land with two small barns that would shelter the sheep and llamas. Except for small gardens adjacent to the house, most of the land would be fenced for pasture. The site finally chosen for the house was a nearly level meadow encircled by clusters of trees. I envisioned a house that would follow the circular pattern of the trees.

If the rooms were linked together around a courtyard garden, the courtyard could become an outdoor room at the core of the house. If the rooms were not wide, and if there were window and door openings placed on at least two sides of every room, the interior would get plenty of light. The house that was taking shape in my imagination shared some features with a traditional Japanese house. A garden placed at the center of the house and movable shoji screens (wooden frames with translucent rice-paper panels) to dissolve the barriors between interior spaces and the landscape are common elements in Japanese house design.


Units of measure-

In his book Measure and Construction of the Japanese House (Charles E. Tuttle Co., 1985), Heino Engel suggests that the Japanese were the first to apply a standard unit of measure to a building system. The standard unit (called ken) is the distance between supporting posts, and this distance controls the scale, the proportion and the form of a building. Traditional Japanese carpenters were so familiar with the system that they could creat an entire house from a floor plan drawn by their clients. And they could manipulate spaces, knowing that the scale and the proportion of every room would be in harmony with the rest of the building.

If I wanted to borrow from the Japanese tradition, I would need to approach the design systematically. I decided to organize the floor plan on a 4-ft. module, which is compatible with Western building materials. Dimensions of 4 ft. by 8 ft. and 4 ft. by 12 ft. nicely accommodate stress-skin panels and plasterboard. Posts centered pm 4-ft. grid lines leave regularly spaced openings for windows and doors. Multiples of four can also make good room sizes-12 ft. for bedrooms and kitchens, 16 ft. and 20 ft. for living rooms, 8 ft. for bathrooms and 4 ft. for halls.

I arranged the designated room areas on the grid and drew sections showing approximate post and rafter locations. I worked between the plan and the sections, using the grid to establish wall and ceiling heights. It was exciting to see how the plan remained cohesive as the rooms changed sizes and shifted positions.

The U-shaped plan that finally emerged (drawing above right) is composed of three large rectangles and two smaller ones offset, as they might be in a typical Japanese house where the offsets help define outdoor spaces.


One rectange-the living/dining room-is one step lower in response to a slight change in the grade.

Rooms are linked to each other by an interior corridor that has several functions. The corridor acts as a circulation axis that bridges the three main zones of the house. It adds 5 ft. of living space to the edge of the kitchen/family room and eventually becomes the library when it reaches the bedroom wing (photo below). In a Japanese house it is typical for both the edge of a room and the veranda to serve as a corridor that links the rooms of the house together.


Western vs. Eastern timber framing-

Although I was satisfied with the floor plan and with the way interior details had begun to take shape, I knew it would be a challenge to design a suitable frame for this house. Western-style timber framing originated in northern Europe. As it is practiced today, this framing style uses widely spaced posts (up to 16 ft. apart) braced by diagonal members. The frame is revealed on the inside but covered on the exterior by sheathing.

The opposite is true of traditional japanese timber frame, in which the posts are spaced more closely, have no diagonal braces and are exposed both inside and outside the building.

The wall of a traditional Japanese house consists of horizontal and vertical wood strips, covered with bamboo lath and plastered with a mixture of mud and straw. To resist lateral forces, such as those applied by strong winds or earthquakes, a Japanese house relies primarily on the flexibility of the frame and on the wall material installed within the frame. The Japanese approach of engineering a timber frame to withstand a force by moving with it is similar to the martial arts practice of redirecting an opponent's thrust back to its source.

For the Lancys' frame, I looked for ways to create Japanese impressions using Western construction methods and materials that our company understands.

To that end, we put more posts into the wall than is typical, using them to define each window and door opening. In prominent places, we used peeled cedar logs to help support the roof, thereby introducing an element that suggests a japanese roof structure. (See photo below).

By the way, the 12-in. dia. cedar logs were cut locally, peeled, cleaned and kerfed to prevent radial checking. Kerfing, a common practice of Japanese carpenters, involves making a straight cut into the heart and along the ful length of the timber. Wedges are driven as far as they will go into the cut, then they are tapped in farther as the timber dries. We faced the cut, with its wedges still in place, toward the ceiling where it was out of sight.


Finishing the exterior-

On most of our timber frames, we use stress-skin panels, which are structural panels made of rigid insulation and waferboard, applied to the exterior face of the frame. But on the Lancy house this technique would have concealed the frame on the outside. I was unwilling to compromise the honesty of the frame by adding trim to imitate the frame on the exterior walls. There was only one solution: the panels would have to be fitted between the timbers. Essentially, we replaced the traditional bamboo, mud and straw with polyurethane insulation and waferboard.

We used 2x4s, routed into the edges of the panels, to connect the panels to the frame. Expanding urethane foam served as a gasket between the two. The 4 1/2-in. thick panels left enough timber exposed to finish the interior and exterior walls with drywall and stucco.

The insulation value of the house does not seem to have been compromised very much. Although we lost the continuity of the panel, we gained the mass of the timbers.

Protecting the exposed Douglas-fir frame from the weather will be an ongoing challenge. Because the Lancys elected not to add an ultraviolet protective stain to the frame (they liked the natural color of the wood), it will be necessary to repply a protective oil coating about every two years.

In a Japanese house the color of the exterior walls would be determined by the kind of earth used in the infill mixture. Because we did not have that option, we colored the latex stucco a rather dark gray with a greenish cast, a color we hoped would help the house recede into the Northwest landscape.


A tour of the inside-

The walkway to the house follows a meandering rock path that begins at the edge of the meadow and leads past a landscape of low pines to the timber-framed pergola that flanks the glass entry doors. Wehen the rock path crosses the threshold, it expands to form the floor of the entry, two steps below the gallery's polished concrete floor.

The Lancys wanted a radiant-floor heating system and had expressed interest in a tile floor. More than 3,000 sq. ft. of tile would have taken a big bite out of the construction budget, so I suggested concrete as an alternative.

We discovered an acid etching compound that, when applied to finished concrete, gives it a transparent color (Kemiko Stone Tone Concrete Stain, Epmar Corp., P.O. Box 3925, Santa Fe Springs, Calif. 90670; 310-946-8781). The transparency allows variations caused by the minerals in the concrete to show through. When the surface is sealed and waxed, it resembles glazed ceramic tile. Because it was scored into rectangular blocks, our floor pattern suggests Japanese tatami mats with their dark tape binding.

The living room combines sitting and formal dining areas. Low cabinets, designed to store prints and ceramic sculpture, line one wall. Wood for all of the cabinetry in the house was taken from the same resawn Douglas-fir timbers used in the structure.

Clearly, the large amount of glazing in the Lancy house is a major departure from the Japanese tradition. The windows were designed to fit into the frame without sills. They slide open in the wall plane and are placed low on the wall.

In spite of its broad eaves, the house is filled with light. We made sure of this by adding skylights in strategic places. Skylights in the veranda roof (photo below) let light shine through the glass doors and into the kitchen. Fourteen other 2-ft. by 2-ft. skylights were placed between rafters on the north and west slopes of the roof.

Although the Lancys are fond of shoji screens, their lifestyle precluded the use of these fragile panels. So we settled for sandblasted glass panels with wooden grids in the clerestory spaces above windows and doors (photo above left). In a Japanese house panels called ramma are found in this space. Our grids are designed to be removed easily for cleaning.

The kitchen cabinets, arranged in an L shape around a 6-ft. island, are a complete departure from any Japanese influence (photo below). Because a modern kitchen has no precedence in a vernacular house, we approached the kitchen from a craftsman's perspective and made the cabinets seem more like furniture. They were built by Michael Hamilton, the cabinetmaker who runs our company's cabinet shop, and modeled after cabinets Annette had seen in a catalog from Smallbone, the British cabinet company.

At the center of the house, both literally and figuratively, the kitchen is a cheery spot, lit by doors and windows on two sides and by skylights in the roof. Peter and Annette spend much of their time in the kitchen-eating, reading and talking. And as the room most likely to hold a spot of sunlight, the kitchen is also where the Lancys' dogs are usually found, curled up and asleep on the floor.


Judith Landau is a designer who, with her husband, Charles Landau, runs Timbercraft Homes in Port Townsend, Wash. Photos by Kevin Ireton.